top of page

Baked Goods



Christmas Cookie Decorating Kits




Christmas Cookie Decorating Kit

This box includes: 6 baked from scratch sugar cookies, 2 bags of homemade vanilla buttercream in green and white colors, and 3 mixed bags of sprinkles to decorate your creations.

$14.95

Christmas Cookie Decorating Kit



Cakes




Cookie Cake

One or two layers of delicious chocolate chip or sugar cookie topped and filled with vanilla buttercream frosting. Please include any color(s) you want included on the cake.

Chocolate Chip Single Layer

$25


Chocolate Chip Double Layer

$45


Sugar Cookie Single Layer

$25


Sugar Cookie Double Layer

$45

Cookie Cake


8x8 Basic Cake

An 8x8 cake topped with buttercream served in 3 different flavors. There are no extra decorations added, all cakes will come with a standard buttercream decoration.

Vanilla

$25


Double Chocolate

$25


Peanut Butter Cup

$25

8x8 Basic Cake



Cupcakes




Confetti Party

Vanilla confetti cake topped with a traditional sweet vanilla buttercream and rainbow sprinkles.

Half Dozen

$16.99


Full Dozen

$28.99

Confetti Party


Vanilla with Vanilla

Classic Madagascar vanilla cake topped with a traditional sweet vanilla buttercream and white sanding sugar.

Half Dozen

$16.99


Full Dozen

$28.99

Vanilla with Vanilla


Vanilla with Chocolate

Classic Madagascar vanilla cake topped with a rich chocolate buttercream and clear sanding sugar.

Half Dozen

$16.99


Full Dozen

$28.99

Vanilla with Chocolate


Double Chocolate

Decadent chocolate cake topped with a rich chocolate buttercream and clear sanding sugar.

Half Dozen

$16.99


Full Dozen

$28.99

Double Chocolate


Peanut Butter Cup

Decadent chocolate cake topped with peanut butter buttercream and a mini peanut butter cup.

Half Dozen

$16.99


Full Dozen

$28.99

Peanut Butter Cup


Chocolate Vanilla

Decadent chocolate cake topped with a traditional sweet vanilla buttercream and chocolate sprinkles.

Half Dozen

$16.99


Full Dozen

$28.99

Chocolate Vanilla


Lemon-Up

Lemon cake infused with lemon lime soda topped with a lemon buttercream and yellow sanding sugar.

Half Dozen

$16.99


Full Dozen

$28.99

Lemon-Up


Red Velvet

Light chocolate buttery cake topped with a smooth cream cheese frosting and red sanding sugar.

Half Dozen

$16.99


Full Dozen

$28.99

Red Velvet


Coconut

Rich and fluffy coconut cake topped with a coconut buttercream and shredded coconut.

Half Dozen

$16.99


Full Dozen

$28.99

Coconut


Wedding Bells

Fluffy white almond cake topped with a light almond buttercream and white sprinkles.

Half Dozen

$16.99


Full Dozen

$28.99

Wedding Bells


Pumpkin Spice

Super moist pumpkin cake loaded with pumpkin spice topped with a smooth cream cheese frosting and dusted with cinnamon.

Half Dozen

$16.99


Full Dozen

$28.99

Pumpkin Spice


Caramel Apple Spice

Half Dozen

$16.99


Full Dozen

$28.99

Caramel Apple Spice


Salted Caramel

Fluffy white cake, filled with dulce de leche, topped with a caramel buttercream and drizzled with caramel sauce and flaky sea salt.

1/2 Dozen

$19.50


1 Dozen

$32.50

Salted Caramel


Butter Pecan Moonshine

Butter pecan cake infused with butter pecan moonshine topped with a rich butter pecan buttercream and crushed pecans.

Half Dozen

$16.99


Full Dozen

$28.99

Butter Pecan Moonshine


S'mores

Decadent chocolate cake with a graham cracker bottom topped with a marshmallow buttercream, crushed graham crackers, and a chocolate square.

Half Dozen

$16.99


Full Dozen

$28.99

S'mores


Hot Cocoa

Decadent chocolate cake topped with a marshmallow buttercream, mini marshmallows, crushed peppermint candy, and chocolate chips.

Half Dozen

$16.99


Full Dozen

$28.99

Hot Cocoa


German Chocolate

Decadent chocolate cake with a rich chocolate buttercream filled with an ooey gooey coconut pecan filling.

1/2 Dozen

$19.50


1 Dozen

$32.50

German Chocolate


Cookies & Cream

Moist Oreo cake with a whole Oreo cookie bottom topped with a vanilla buttercream and a mini Oreo.

Half Dozen

$16.99


Full Dozen

$28.99

Cookies & Cream


Golden Cookies & Cream

Like our Cookies & Cream, but with Golden Oreo's.

Half Dozen

$16.99


Full Dozen

$28.99

Golden Cookies & Cream


Orange Dreamsicle

Fresh orange flavored cake topped with an orange buttercream.

Half Dozen

$16.99


Full Dozen

$28.99

Orange Dreamsicle


Cherry Almond Amaretto

Fluffy white almond cake topped with a cherry amaretto buttercream and a maraschino cherry.

Half Dozen

$16.99


Full Dozen

$28.99

Cherry Almond Amaretto


Chocolate Irish Cream

Decadent chocolate cake infused with Bailey's Irish Cream with an Irish Cream buttercream topped with a green sanding sugar.

Half Dozen

$16.99


Full Dozen

$28.99

Chocolate Irish Cream


Cinnamon Swirl

Cinnamon sugar swirled cake topped with a cinnamon buttercream dusted with cinnamon.

Half Dozen

$16.99


Full Dozen

$28.99

Cinnamon Swirl


Peanut Butter Banana

Banana cupcake with peanut butter buttercream and topped with a banana chip.

Half Dozen

$16.99


Full Dozen

$28.99

Peanut Butter Banana


Mocha

Mocha cupcake with an espresso buttercream.

Half Dozen

$16.99


Full Dozen

$28.99

Mocha


Mint Oreo

Chocolate cake with a Mint Oreo baked into the cake with a mint whipped cream frosting and Oreo crumbs.

Half Dozen

$16.99


Full Dozen

$28.99

Mint Oreo


Root Beer Float

Root beer cupcake with a vanilla whipped cream frosting and a gummy root beer candy.

Half Dozen

$16.99


Full Dozen

$28.99

Root Beer Float


Banana Pudding

Banana cupcake with a banana whipped cream frosting topped with a Nilla wafer.

Half Dozen

$16.99


Full Dozen

$28.99

Banana Pudding


Blue Raspberry

Sweet and sour blue raspberry cake topped with a blue raspberry buttercream and a blue raspberry candy.

Half Dozen

$16.99


Full Dozen

$28.99

Blue Raspberry


Cake Batter

Yellow cake with a cake batter buttercream and topped with cake crumbles and sprinkles.

Half Dozen

$16.99


Full Dozen

$28.99

Cake Batter


Cotton Candy

A vanilla cake topped with a pink cotton candy buttercream and a crunchy sweet topping.

Half Dozen

$16.99


Full Dozen

$28.99

Cotton Candy


White Chocolate Peppermint

A peppermint cake topped with a white chocolate peppermint buttercream and a peppermint chocolate candy.

Half Dozen

$16.99


Full Dozen

$28.99

White Chocolate Peppermint


Banana Nutella

Soft banana cupcake filled with Nutella and topped with a Nutella buttercream and a drizzle of Nutella.

1/2 Dozen

$19.50


1 Dozen

$32.50

Banana Nutella


Variety Pack

Choose flavors to create a variety pack of your own! If ordering these, you must call 740-249-4108 starting at 10:00am EST the morning of the pickup/delivery date to choose your flavors. IF YOU DO NOT CALL THE MORNING OF, we will select a variety of flavors for you.

1/2 Dozen

$19.50


1 Dozen

$32.50

Variety Pack



Cookies & Brownies




Brown Butter Chocolate Chip

The best chocolate chip cookies you've ever had. Made with brown butter and sprinkled with flaky sea-salt for a salty, sweet bite.

$19.99

Brown Butter Chocolate Chip


Double Chocolate Chip

A chocolate cookie base packed with chocolate chips and sprinkled with flaky sea salt.

$19.99

Double Chocolate Chip


White Chocolate Confetti

Sugar cookie dough filled with white chocolate chips and confetti chips for a great light flavor.

$19.99

White Chocolate Confetti


Iced Sugar

Traditional almond sugar cookies frosted with homemade sweet buttercream frosting.

$24.99

Iced Sugar


Oatmeal M&M

Oatmeal cookie base filled with M&M's for a perfect soft chewy bite.

$19.99

Oatmeal M&M


Snickerdoodle

Butter based sugar cookie full of cinnamon and covered in cinnamon sugar.

$19.99

Snickerdoodle


Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip

Classic peanut butter cookie full of chocolate chips.

$19.99

Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip


Blueberry Muffin Top Cookie

The best part of a blueberry muffin, now in cookie form. Blueberry muffin cookies topped with a streusel topping.

$19.99

Blueberry Muffin Top Cookie


Soft Pumpkin Cookies

The softest pumpkin cookies you've ever had. Packed with warm spices and drizzled with a cream cheese glaze.

$19.99

Soft Pumpkin Cookies


Peanut Butter Cookies

A classic peanut butter cookie rolled in sugar.

$19.99

Peanut Butter Cookies


Triple Chocolate Brownies

Melted Chocolate chips, cocoa powder, and chocolate chip mix-ins combine for a perfect fudgy chocolate brownie and sprinkled with flaky sea salt. Sold in an 8x8 pan.

$20

Triple Chocolate Brownies


Iced Chocolate Brownies

Triple Chocolate Brownies topped with a rich chocolate buttercream. Sold in an 8x8 pan.

$22.50

Iced Chocolate Brownies


German Chocolate Brownies

Triple Chocolate Brownies topped with German chocolate frosting. Sold in an 8x8 pan.

$25

German Chocolate Brownies


Brown Butter Blondies

Thick cookie bar with notes of brown sugar and brown butter. Crisp edges with a soft inside...irresistible. Sold in an 8x8 pan.

$20

Brown Butter Blondies


White Chocolate Brownies

Brownies made with melted white chocolate chips and topped with even more chips. Sold in an 8x8 pan.

$22.50

White Chocolate Brownies


Red Velvet Cheesecake Brownies

Red velvet brownies swirled with a traditional cheesecake. Sold in an 8x8 pan.

$25

Red Velvet Cheesecake Brownies



Other Goodies




Cookie Truffles

Rich cookie truffle, blended with cream cheese and coated in smooth almond bark.

Oreo

$22.99


Golden Oreo

$22.99


Mint Oreo

$22.99


Cookie Butter

Cookie Truffles


Tres Leches Cake

A sweet, moist cake soaked in "Tres Leches" (evaporated milk, condensed milk, and whole milk), topped with a homemade whipped cream. Available in Vanilla, Strawberry, and Cookies & Cream, specify which flavor in the order notes!

$20

Tres Leches Cake


Cheesecake Bites

No bake cheesecake filled with your choice of cookie, with a cookie base and topped with a drizzle and our homemade whipped cream.

Oreo

$34.99


Golden Oreo

$34.99


Mint Oreo

$34.99


Cookie Butter

$34.99

Cheesecake Bites

Like and Follow us!

  • Instagram
  • Facebook

© 2022 by Bakery 323. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page